Savings · 3 min read

Gas vs Electric Heating: Which Is Actually Cheaper?

Smart home energy display showing household consumption
Photo: LindaInpijn (CC BY-SA 4.0)

"Is gas or electric cheaper to heat my home?" has a frustrating but honest answer: it depends on three things — local fuel prices, the efficiency of the equipment, and your climate. Get those three right and the comparison is straightforward. This guide shows the method, not a one-size answer, because the real answer is different in different homes. For local prices, start with our electricity cost by state data.

Why you can't compare the bills directly

A gas bill is priced in therms and an electric bill in kilowatt-hours (kWh) — different units for different energy. Comparing the dollar amounts tells you nothing until you convert both to the same thing: cost per unit of useful heat delivered into your home. Two numbers drive that conversion:

  1. The price of each fuel (from your bills).
  2. The efficiency of the equipment turning that fuel into heat.

That second number is where the surprises live.

The efficiency factor that changes everything

  • A gas furnace turns most of the fuel into heat — high-efficiency models convert the large majority of the gas into usable warmth.
  • Electric resistance heat (baseboards, old furnaces) converts essentially all the electricity into heat — but you're paying for generated heat.
  • A heat pump is the outlier: it doesn't generate heat, it moves heat from outside to inside. For each unit of electricity it can deliver several units of heat. That multiplier is why an electric heat pump often beats gas even when electricity costs more per unit.

So the matchup isn't really "gas vs electric." It's usually gas furnace vs electric heat pump, with old-style electric resistance as the expensive option to avoid for whole-home heating.

The typical ranking (and why it flips)

In rough, general terms:

Heating type Usual cost to run Best when
Electric resistance (baseboard) Highest Rarely used rooms, very mild climates
Gas furnace Low–moderate Cheap local gas, very cold climates
Heat pump Low (often lowest) Moderate climates, higher electricity-but-moving-heat math

This ranking flips with your climate and prices: where gas is cheap and winters are brutal, a gas furnace (or a heat pump with gas backup) often wins; where winters are milder or electricity is reasonable, a heat pump usually wins outright. See heat pump savings for that case in detail.

How to run the numbers for your home

  1. Get your prices. Find the price per therm (gas) and per kWh (electricity) on your latest bills.
  2. Note your equipment's efficiency. Furnace efficiency is on its rating; a heat pump's effective multiplier depends on the model and outdoor temperature.
  3. Convert both to cost per unit of delivered heat and compare. The lower number wins for running cost.
  4. Then weigh the upfront cost. Equipment price, installation and any available incentives change the payback, even when running costs are close.

The bottom line

There's no universal winner — but there is a universal method. For most moderate climates, a modern heat pump is now the cheapest way to heat, beating both gas and old electric heat. In the coldest regions with cheap gas, a gas furnace (often paired with a heat pump) still competes. Run your own prices through the steps above, then use our how to lower your electric bill guide and state electricity prices to see where you stand.

FAQ

Is gas or electric heating cheaper?

Historically, a gas furnace has been cheaper to run than old-style electric resistance heat in most places, because natural gas usually costs less per unit of heat. But a modern heat pump — which is electric — can beat gas in many climates because it moves heat instead of generating it, delivering several times more heat per unit of energy.

Does a heat pump work in cold weather?

Modern cold-climate heat pumps work well below freezing, far better than older models. In very cold regions many homes use a heat pump for most of the season with a backup (gas or electric) for the coldest stretches — often the cheapest overall setup.

How do I compare my own gas and electric costs?

Convert both to cost per unit of delivered heat. Gas is priced per therm and electricity per kWh; factoring in each system's efficiency lets you compare them fairly. Your utility bills have the prices; the sections below explain the method.